“Many Thousands Gone"
By: Chandler Carlson
In
the passage from “Many Thousands Gone”, James Baldwin concludes that white is
the only acceptable color in America at that time. “The general desire seems to
be to make it blank if one cannot make it white” (26). The Negro has no
identity, but is instead thought of as disturbing statistics of “slums, rapes,
injustices, remote violence” (26). Baldwin went on to say that the Negro is thought
of as a cancer, “which cannot be cured” (25). For this reason, American society
finds it easier and more convenient to not associate faces to the Negro because
that would make him more human and less of the cancer society is comfortable
with regarding him as.
A
statistic is just a number. It has no positive or negative connotation. It has
no feelings. Society considered the black population as the statistics of
tragic and violent events. White Americans associated the Negro to something as
numb as a number because they could not face the guilt of the injustices that
confronted him. So society felt more comfortable keeping the Negro at an arm’s
length. They instead clumped every black individual together and made untried
generalizations. “If he breaks out sociological and sentimental image of him we
are panic-stricken and we feel ourselves betrayed” (25). The white American had
its assumptions about the Negro and was comfortable with those assumptions. This
is why Baldwin said that a face that is not white is made blank because the
guilt of the assumptions and generalizations is easier to bear when those
affected aren’t similar to us. Instead, “the loss of our own identity is the
price we pay for our annulment of his” (25). The face of the Negro is left blank
because he would be too similar to the white American if his face were
recognizable.
Frantz
Fanon discusses “Native Son” in his “1952 essay L'Experience Vecue du Noir, or ‘The Fact of Blackness’. ‘In the
end,’ writes Fanon, ‘Bigger Thomas acts. To put an end to his tension, he acts,
he responds to the world's anticipation.’” (Wiki) Frantz’s words are disturbing
because he recognizes that the murder Bigger committed was what society expected.
It ended their anticipation and fulfilled their expectation for the Negro. Baldwin
explains, “The courtroom, judge, jury, witnesses and spectators, recognize
immediately that Bigger is their creation and they recognize this not only with
hatred and fear and guilt and the resulting fury of self-righteousness but also
with that morbid fullness of pride mixed with horror with which one regards the
extent and power of one’s wickedness” (43). By perpetuating the practice of
seeing a blank face where there was a black face, society denied the Negro the
opportunity to escape the lurking and relentless expectation of society.
Chandler,
ReplyDeleteReally nice work! You point out a number of aspects of Baldwin's argument and relate them directly to the themes of Wright's novel.
Your explanation of Baldwin's discussion of statistics is spot on, as are your observations regarding blankness. When we get around to reading _Native Son_ I am curious how these remarks will resonate. At the beginning of the novel, Bigger appears totally blank to others and problematically black to himself. Later he comes to a different understanding of his race and while he appears problematically (statistically) black to others, inside he is the farthest from being blank than he has ever been.
Thanks for this contribution.